Weekly Case

Title : case 209

Age / Sex : 38 / F




Age / Sex :  38/ Female



Chief complaint : Spontaneously developed sudden knee joint pain, left






1) What is your impression?



Two weeks later, you can see the final diagnosis with a brief discussion of
this case.



* Send Application Answers to In Sook Lee, MD (lis@pusan.ac.kr)



Courtesy : Juhng Seon Kwan, Wonkwang University Sch of Med & Hosp




Diagnosis:

Spontaneous Osteonecrosis of knee (SONK)



Discussion




Findings:.



Knee plain radiograph shows a focal crescentic area
surrounded by band of sclerosis in medial femoral condyle, with mild bony collapse.



RI bone scan of both knees shows a focal hot uptake in the left medial
femoral condyle.



MRI shows a focal area of subchondral collapse with separation of
osteochondral fragment and adjacent bone marrow edema and complex tear of
medial meniscus.



 



Differential Diagnosis:



Osteochondritis Dissecans (OCD)



Subchondral Fracture



Stress Response/Fracture



Osteoarthritis



 



Diagnosis:
 



Spontaneous
Osteonecrosis of knee (SONK)



 



Discussion:



SONK =
Spontaeneous OsteoNecrosis of Knee = Ahlbäck disease



-Necrosis of
weight-bearing portion of femur or tibia with associated subchondral fracture
and collapse



-Middle-aged
and elderly patients, F>M



-can be
associated with meniscal tears



-Etiology:
(controversial)



Traumatic theory:
osteoporotic patient suffers insufficiency fracture following trivial trauma,
bone subsequently becomes necrotic



Vascular theory:
thrombotic venous occlusion leading to venous hypertension and hypoxic death;
recently less accepted in the knee



-Radiographic
Findings:



(+/-) Subchondral sclerosis



(+/-) Articular surface collapse



Effusion



-MR Findings:



T1WI: Necrosis:
discrete area of subchondral decreased SI



Surrounded by intermediate signal
(combination of fat and edema)



T2WI: Focus of low SI
ischemia or fracture surrounded by diffuse increased SI edema



(+/-) Linear often serpiginous low
signal abnormality adjacent to edema (probable fracture)



(+/-) Articular surface collapse



 



References:



Björkengren
AG, AlRowaih A, Lindstrand A, Wingstrand H, Thorngren KG, Pettersson H.
Spontaneous osteonecrosis of the knee:value of MR imaging in determining
prognosis.
AJR Am
J Roentgenol
. 1990 Feb;154(2):331-6



M. Takeda, H. Higuchi, M. Kimura, Y. Kobayashi, M.
Terauchi, and K. Takagishi

Spontaneous osteonecrosis of the
knee: HISTOPATHOLOGICAL DIFFERENCES BETWEEN EARLY AND PROGRESSIVE CASES

J Bone Joint Surg Br. 2008; 90-B(3): 324 - 329.



Correct Answer
Name Institution
total applicants 29
correct answer 16
이상희 삼성서울병원
김철영 이춘택병원
박희진 강북삼성병원
서영주 (전공의) 세브란스병원
윤민아: 서울대병원
김은지 바른세상병원
하종수 새움병원
최희석 부평세림병원
안경식 고대안암병원
김인환 전북대병원
오형우 광주21세기병원
이경규 한강성심병원
홍새롬 (전공의) 세브란스병원
박상현 플러스메디영상의학과
강평국 옹익병원
이승훈 한양대병원
semi-correct answer 2
이호준 국군양주병원
최성규 스마일영상의학과

Comment